Nichols mener at de forskjellige modi har gradvis utviklet seg og han har laget et lite kart som jeg har kopiert og nå viser her.
Table s. 138 i Introduction to Documentary
Documentary Modes
Chief Characteristics
-Deficiencies
Chief Characteristics
-Deficiencies
Hollywood fiction (1910s)
Fictional narratives of imaginary worlds
-absence of reality
Fictional narratives of imaginary worlds
-absence of reality
Poetic documentary (1920s)
Reassemble fragments of the world poetically
-Lack of specificity, too abstract
Expository documentary (1920s)
directly addresses issues in the historical world
-overly didactic
Observational documentary (1960s)
eschew commentary and reenactment, observe things as they happen
-lack of history, context
Participatory documentary (1960s)
interview or interact with subjects; use archival film or retrieve history
-excessive faith in witnesses, naïve history, too intrusive
Reflexive documentary (1980s)
Question documentary form, defamiliarize the other modes.
-To abstract, lose sight of actual issues
Performative documentary (1980s)
stress subjective aspects of a classically object discourse
-loss of emphasis on objectivity may relegate such films to the avant-garde; “Excessive” use of style
-overly didactic
Observational documentary (1960s)
eschew commentary and reenactment, observe things as they happen
-lack of history, context
Participatory documentary (1960s)
interview or interact with subjects; use archival film or retrieve history
-excessive faith in witnesses, naïve history, too intrusive
Reflexive documentary (1980s)
Question documentary form, defamiliarize the other modes.
-To abstract, lose sight of actual issues
Performative documentary (1980s)
stress subjective aspects of a classically object discourse
-loss of emphasis on objectivity may relegate such films to the avant-garde; “Excessive” use of style
”To some extent, each mode of documentary representation arises in part through a growing sense of dissatisfaction among filmmakers with a previous mode. In this sense the modes do convey some sense of documentary history.” (s. 100)
Ingen kommentarer:
Legg inn en kommentar